Uncovering the Truth: How Cardio Affects Your Muscle Gains According to Reddit

AvatarByJeff Duncan Cardio

When it comes to fitness and exercise, there are endless debates and conflicting opinions. One such controversial topic is the effect of cardio on muscle gains. While some swear by the benefits of cardio for overall health and weight loss, others believe it can hinder muscle growth. This debate has sparked a heated discussion on Reddit, with many fitness enthusiasts chiming in on their own experiences and theories. So, what’s the truth? Does cardio really kill muscle gains or is it just a myth perpetuated by gym bros? In this article, we’ll dig deeper into this question and uncover the truth behind cardio and muscle gains according to the Reddit community.

The Relationship Between Cardio and Muscle Gains

Cardio and muscle gains are two topics that often come up when discussing fitness and achieving a lean, muscular physique. For many people, the goal of hitting the gym is to gain muscle mass while burning fat. However, questions often arise about the impact that cardio has on muscle gains. Some may wonder if cardio will help or hinder their progress towards building a more muscular frame.

What is Cardio?

Cardio, short for cardiovascular, refers to any activity that elevates your heart rate for an extended period of time. It is typically associated with activities such as running, cycling, swimming, and even dancing. These activities increase your heart rate and help to improve your overall cardiovascular health.

The Benefits of Cardio

There are numerous benefits associated with incorporating cardio into your fitness routine. First and foremost, it helps to improve your overall heart health by strengthening your heart muscle and improving blood flow throughout the body. Cardio also helps to increase lung capacity and can even improve mental health by reducing stress and anxiety.

Additionally, regular cardio sessions can aid in weight loss by burning calories and fat. It can also be a great way to maintain muscle definition while shedding excess body fat.

Can Cardio Kill Muscle Gains?

Now that we have established what cardio is and its benefits, let’s address the main question at hand – does cardio kill muscle gains? To put it simply: no, it does not.

In fact, incorporating moderate amounts of cardio into your routine can actually benefit your muscle gains in several ways:

1) Improved Recovery: Cardio helps to increase blood flow throughout the body, which carries oxygen and essential nutrients to muscles. This can aid in muscle recovery after weight training sessions.
2) Increased Endurance: By improving your cardiovascular health through regular cardio sessions, you will have more endurance to push through challenging weight lifting exercises. This can lead to increased muscle gains over time.
3) Lower Body Fat: Excess body fat can mask muscle definition, making it difficult to see the progress you’ve made in the gym. By incorporating cardio into your fitness routine, you will burn more calories and reduce body fat, allowing your muscles to become more visible.

The Importance of Balance

While cardio can be beneficial for muscle gains, balance is key. Too much cardio can lead to negative effects on muscle growth. For example, if you are doing hours of intense cardio every day, your body may enter a catabolic state where it breaks down muscle tissue for energy.

Additionally, excessive cardio can lead to fatigue and make it challenging to perform at your best during weight training sessions. This can hinder muscle gains in the long run.

Aim for moderate amounts of cardio each week – around 3-5 sessions lasting 20-30 minutes each should be sufficient for most people looking to maintain overall health and improve their physique.

How to Incorporate Cardio into Your Fitness Routine

Now that we have established that cardio is not detrimental to muscle gains, let’s explore how you can incorporate it into your fitness routine:

1) Choose Low Impact Activities: If your primary goal is building muscle mass, high impact activities such as running may not be the best choice as they can put additional stress on your muscles and joints. Opt for low impact activities such as cycling or swimming.
2) Consider Cardio After Weight Training: If possible, try scheduling your cardio sessions after weight training workouts. This will allow your body to focus on building and repairing muscles during weight training before moving onto cardiovascular exercise.
3) Use HIIT/Interval Training: High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) has been gaining popularity in recent years due to its numerous benefits including improved cardiovascular health and calorie burn. This type of training involves short bursts of intense exercise followed by brief periods of rest, making it an efficient way to incorporate cardio into your routine.
4) Listen to Your Body: Everyone’s fitness journey is unique, and what works for one person may not work for another. It’s crucial to listen to your body and find a balance that works for you. If you feel like too much cardio is hindering your muscle gains, adjust accordingly.

The Bottom Line

In summary, incorporating moderate amounts of cardio into your fitness routine can actually benefit muscle gains rather than hinder them. Cardio helps with recovery, increases endurance, and aids in reducing body fat – all of which can contribute to building a lean and muscular physique. However, it’s essential to find a balance and avoid excessive amounts of cardio that could potentially hinder muscle growth. As with any aspect of fitness, patience and consistency are key in achieving your desired results. So keep up with your weight training and incorporate some cardio sessions into your routine for optimal results.

Reasons why cardio may not necessarily kill muscle gains

There is a common belief that doing cardio can lead to muscle loss or hinder muscle growth. However, many experts argue that this is not always the case. In fact, incorporating some form of cardio into your workout routine can actually benefit your overall muscle gain goals. Here are some reasons why:

1. Improved cardiovascular health can support better workouts

One of the main benefits of incorporating cardio into your workout routine is improved cardiovascular health. This means that your heart and lungs become more efficient at supplying oxygen and nutrients to your muscles during exercise. So, by improving your cardiovascular health through cardio, you are actually supporting better and more intense workouts.

When you have better cardiovascular health, you will have more energy to push yourself during weightlifting sessions and potentially lift heavier weights. This means that cardio can indirectly contribute to building more muscle mass.

2. Cardio promotes better recovery

In order for our muscles to grow, they need time to recover and repair after being broken down during exercise. Incorporating some form of low intensity steady state (LISS) cardio after weightlifting sessions can actually promote better recovery.

LISS cardio helps remove lactic acid build-up in the muscles, which can cause soreness and fatigue. By clearing out this lactic acid, you will experience less soreness and fatigue, allowing you to hit the weights harder in your next session.

3. Cardio can improve nutrient delivery

Cardio helps improve blood flow in the body, which means more oxygen-rich blood reaches different areas of the body, including the muscles. This increase in blood flow can aid in delivering important nutrients to the muscles for growth and repair.

Additionally, doing cardio before a weightlifting session can also help warm up your muscles and prepare them for intense activity. This increased blood flow can also help your muscles recover faster after a tough workout.

4. Increased nutrient demands

Performing cardio on a regular basis can increase your body’s demand for nutrients. This means that incorporating cardio into your routine can actually stimulate muscle growth by signaling the body to increase its intake of essential nutrients.

Cardio can also increase insulin sensitivity, which means that your body is better able to regulate blood sugar levels and use carbohydrates for energy rather than storing them as fat. This can be extremely beneficial for building and maintaining muscle mass.

5. Variety in training

Constantly lifting weights with no variation in training can lead to plateauing and eventually hinder muscle gains. By incorporating cardio into your routine, you are adding variety and challenging your body in different ways.

This variety in training can help improve overall strength, as well as prevent boredom and mental fatigue from repetitive weightlifting exercises.

Strategies for combining cardio with weightlifting for optimal results

In order to reap the benefits mentioned above, it is important to effectively combine cardio with weightlifting. Here are some strategies you can incorporate into your workout routine:

1. Determine the right balance

The key to combining cardio and weightlifting is finding the right balance between the two forms of exercise. This will depend on factors such as your goals, fitness level, and time constraints.

If muscle gain is your primary goal, it is recommended to focus more on weightlifting while still incorporating some form of cardiovascular activity into your routine. High intensity interval training (HIIT) may be a better option for building intense bursts of energy without sacrificing muscle mass.

However, if overall fitness and health is your priority, then a more balanced approach between weightlifting and cardio may be beneficial.

2. Schedule accordingly

When planning out your workouts for the week, it is important to consider when to incorporate cardio. While some people prefer doing cardio before weightlifting, others may find it more effective to do it after.

Performing cardio before weightlifting may help warm up the body and prepare muscles for intense activity. Doing it after weightlifting can also help with recovery and promote better nutrient delivery to the muscles.

3. Use proper nutrition and tracking techniques

In order to effectively combine cardio and weightlifting, it is important to properly fuel your body with the right nutrients. This includes consuming enough protein to support muscle growth, as well as carbohydrates and healthy fats for energy.

Tracking your nutrient intake and workouts can also help you determine what works best for your body. You may find that certain forms of cardio or a specific timing of when you do cardio leads to better muscle gains.

4. Don’t overdo it

While incorporating cardio into your routine can have many benefits, it is important not to overdo it. Too much cardio can lead to fatigue and hinder muscle growth.

It is recommended to start slow and gradually increase the amount of cardio in your routine, while still prioritizing weightlifting as your main form of exercise for building muscle.

In

Q: Does doing cardio hinder muscle gains?

A: It depends on the type and duration of cardio. High-intensity and long-duration cardio can potentially interfere with muscle growth.

Q: Will doing cardio burn off my muscle?

A: If you are in a calorie deficit for an extended period, then there is a possibility of losing muscle mass, but including appropriate strength training and protein intake can help prevent this.

Q: Can I do both weight lifting and cardio without losing muscle?

A: Yes, it is possible to do both weightlifting and cardio to maintain or even build muscle. However, proper nutrition and recovery are crucial factors in achieving this balance.

Q: How much cardio can I do without losing muscle?

A: The amount of cardio that you can safely incorporate into your workout routine without risking muscle loss will vary depending on individual factors such as current fitness level, goals, and nutrition intake. It is best to consult with a personal trainer or fitness expert for personalized recommendations.

Q: Is it better to do cardio before or after lifting weights?

A: The timing of your cardio session in relation to weightlifting depends on your goals. If your main focus is building strength and muscle mass, then doing weightlifting first would be more beneficial. However, if improving cardiovascular endurance is your goal, then starting with a bout of cardio would be ideal.

Q: Will adding short bursts of intense cardio affect my muscle gains?

A: Short bursts of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) have been shown to have minimal impact on muscle gains while providing numerous health benefits. However, it is essential to listen to your body and adjust accordingly if you start noticing any negative effects on your progress.

In conclusion, the discussion on whether cardio kills muscle gains on Reddit has been a hotly debated topic among fitness enthusiasts. After examining various perspectives and scientific evidence, it can be concluded that certain types of cardio, such as high-intensity interval training (HIIT), can negatively impact muscle gains if not managed properly.

One of the main factors to consider is the energy balance – consuming enough calories to support both muscle growth and cardiovascular activity. When in a caloric deficit, cardio can interfere with muscle protein synthesis and lead to muscle loss. However, when in a caloric surplus, cardio can actually aid in fat loss while preserving muscle mass.

Furthermore, the type and duration of cardio also play a crucial role. Long-duration steady-state cardio (e.g. running long distances) has been shown to have a greater negative impact on muscle gains compared to high-intensity, short-duration forms like sprints or plyometrics. Incorporating different types of cardio and varying the duration can also prevent adaptation and promote overall fitness.

Another factor to consider is individual differences – some people may respond better to certain forms of cardio while others may not. It’s important for individuals to experiment and find what works best for them. Additionally, incorporating proper nutrition and rest is essential for maintaining muscle gains while incorporating

Author Profile

Avatar
Jeff Duncan
Jeff Duncan, the owner and Head Coach of CrossFit Pearl District, is dedicated to fostering a supportive and effective training environment.

With a strong belief in the principles of movement mechanics, consistency, and intensity, Jeff has cultivated a community that thrives on continuous improvement and mutual support.

From 2024, Jeff Duncan has expanded his passion for CrossFit beyond coaching by writing an informative blog dedicated to the CrossFit niche. His blog features a variety of content aimed at providing valuable information and insights to the CrossFit community.

Jeff’s posts cover a wide range of topics including training techniques, nutrition advice, workout routines, and answers to common queries within the niche. This transition to blogging allows Jeff to reach a broader audience, sharing his expertise and helping individuals at all levels of their fitness journey.